Roy Exum: The State’s New Proposal

Friday, February 9, 2018 - by Roy Exum
Roy Exum
Roy Exum

Just moments before Candace McQueen presented a new proposal that would allow the state to help fix five poorly-performing schools in Hamilton County’s poverty areas, Jill Levine could not contain her smile nor hide her emotions any longer. “It’s good … It’s really good…” she stage-whispered as McQueen, the state’s Commissioner of Education, faced the school board late Thursday afternoon.

The one person in the whole room I wanted to see happy with the state’s proposal was the dynamic Levine because, since the opening of school, she has totally poured herself into about a dozen schools that need intensive care. She above all others knows there is a way to reach, educate, and nurture today’s children who – through no fault of their own – are getting left behind. If a child in a poverty situation cannot measure up on the first day of kindergarten, when will that precious human being ever catch up?

For a year and a half the state’s McQueen has threatened to pirate Chattanooga’s five troubled iZone schools into something called the Achievement School District that failed miserably in Memphis over the past five years. Today there are seven Memphis charter school that are being threatened to close, millions of dollars have been wasted and lost, and there is very little improvement to be found.

So when McQueen first started in Chattanooga, she proposed a foolish second school board, removing the five schools and all the children from any control by a Hamilton County educator, and embarking on a hare-brained scheme that would add insult to the misery in a school district where a full 60 percent of its third graders are unable to read at grade level.

In the past two years it has been discovered that wanton neglect by the elected school board and the elected County Commission have created horrific problems for public education. School buildings have been blatantly ignored, county officials have placed themselves over what is best for children, and leadership within the system has been allowed to decay miserably.

The roller-coaster ride is far from over but a “Godsend” in the millage rate, coupled with a zealous drive to hire a formidable superintendent in Bryan Johnson, and a renewed push by the community towards public education, has been notably impressive. McQueen said as much last night and offered a plan - believe it or not - had a sincerity and earnestness that shows “the state” is back to being “us.”

Gone is the scheme to rewrite school board laws. Total governance in the new partnership pattern will come totally from people elected by the people. There will be a seven-person advisory board – with four Hamilton County residents selected as state representatives and three more from within Hamilton County picked by the school board representatives.

The state will hire a “facilitator” of sorts to help “guide” the five iZone schools – Orchard Knob Elementary, Orchard Knob Middle, Woodmore, Dalewood and Brainerd – but, whoa! When Johnson charged Levin with the “Innovation Zone,” he included others, like Hardy, Barger, The Howard School, East Lake Elementary and Middle. Calvin Donaldson and Clifton Hills were added because many kindred problems are common in the inner city schools.

Don’t you see? Johnson and Levine want to work their magic on more than five and McQueen has promised Levine the state will be happy to help with any other schools she names. “It isn’t a take-over,” Jill said. “This is a partnership and we have a far bigger stake in it than the state.

“The commissioner and her team have been down here for most of the day,” Jill said last night. “We’ve kicked around more ideas, talked about what our weaknesses are …. Believe me, this is far, far, far different than what was scaring you. This is totally based on children. I know you believe the teachers of Hamilton County can do anything … and we can. But sometimes when you say ‘I need a hand’ it strengthens your resolve to accept one.”

Candace McQueen is perhaps in her last year. A new governor brings in a new team and, when the “partnership” is implemented in August of this year, Commissioner McQueen will have less than three months in office unless she can impress the next head of our state. Yeah, she and the school board will sign a five-year deal but – brother – a new administration can run that asunder in no time at all.

Yet that’s not the focus. The True North is the child. Jill Levine tells me this partnership will work, and now it is a partnership. And best of all? “We have a chance.”

royexum@aol.com


Joda Thongnopnua Is The Best Candidate For House District 30

When voters in Tennessee’s House District 30 head to the polls on Nov. 6, I encourage them to vote for their best interests by voting for Joda Thongnopnua.  I know I will be.   Though I have a history of voting down the right side of the ballot, I don’t care much for party politics — never have, never will. What I try to invest in, politically speaking, lies ... (click for more)

Blessed Inclusion

The Pride Festival at Ross's Landing was an amazing event. Many thanks to everyone involved.   The Pride Mass at Grace Episcopal Church was also superb. Many thanks to Rev. April Berends and her staff. The Scripture Readings, Hymns and the Homily were all centered around inclusion. It was assuring to hear that all of us in the LGBTQ community are God's children. God ... (click for more)

City Placing New Penalties On Use Of Cell Phones In School Zone And By Drivers Under 18

The city is setting new penalties for use of cell phones in school zones.  Drivers 18 and older may not use hand-held devices while in the zones, but they can be on their hands-free units. Another section of an ordinance change would not allow those 18 and under to be talking on a cell phone while driving. That includes even if the device is hands-free. The ordinance ... (click for more)

Rhea Puppy Mill Dogs Slowly Recovering From Years Of Abuse, Neglect

Five days after Watson and 108 other dogs were rescued from a dark, filthy puppy mill in Rhea County, the frightened 12-pound Yorkie mix doesn’t look like the same animal. Watson got lucky; he was one of the 28 puppy mill survivors that wound up at Chattanooga’s Humane Educational Society. There, volunteer groomers from Pet Smart shaved away the heavy, massive tangle of ... (click for more)

Vols Take First SEC Win Of The Season On The Road At #21 Auburn

Tennessee outscored No. 21/21 Auburn 17-7 in the final two quarters of Saturday's game to earn its first road and SEC win of the season at Jordan-Hare Stadium. "We beat a really good football team today," head coach Jeremy Pruitt said. "It's like I told them in there, if we learn to execute and raise our level of fight, we've got a chance to have a really good football ... (click for more)

Mocs Take Road Win At Western Carolina, 26-6

The Chattanooga Mocs shut down Western Carolina’s vibrant offensive attack in a 26-6 triumph in Whitmire Stadium Saturday afternoon. The Catamounts had not scored less than 28 points in a game all season. The Mocs had not allowed more than 24 in regulation. Something had to give. It was not the UTC defense as it held its hosts nearly 30 points (29.8) below their season average. ... (click for more)